What Do Vibrators & Sepsis Have in Common?

Answer: The movie Hysteria and very little else (but exceptions unfortunately exist). 

I can't resist commenting on mentions of infectious diseases in popular media. As I've written before, these mentions often give a snapshot of how the general public views a particular topic whether it is HIV, Ebola, or influenza.

Hysteria is a somewhat fictional account of the invention of the vibrator in 19th century England as well aa a critique of the diagnosing of hysteria--a nebulous term that, when applied to a woman, horrifically could led to a hysterectomy for no reason. The film accurately depicts hysteria as akin to blood-letting, leeches (which do have a few legitimate medicinal uses), and the "laudable pus" that emanated from infected wounds.

In the movie Dr. Mortimer Granville, the real inventor of the vibrator, is portrayed as an innovative, evidence-based, and modern physician railing against treatments that are ineffective or do harm. In one of the opening scenes, Dr. Granville has an important exchange with a nurse instructing her to remove dirty bandages from wounds because of the risk of sepsis, a word derived from the Greek term for "to make rotten".

As an infectious disease and critical care medicine physician, sepsis--a systemic inflammatory state induced by infection with microorganisms--is something I can't avoid seeing upon setting foot in the hospital but the concept was completely foreign to medicine until the germ theory was developed and accepted. No embrace of antisepsis and sterility could really occur if there was no realization that microbes could cause disease. "I don't think I have those," the patient in the scene remarks and indeed it would be impossible for a person without the context of the germ theory to imagine invisible organisms as being responsible for a state of disease.

The senior physician remarks that "germ theory is poppycock" to which Dr. Granville retorts "Lister has proved it."

Today that microorganism can cause disease is not even greeting with disbelief from children, who rush to have Band-Aids applied to the slightest abrasion. In the end, germ theory--the development of which I hope to write a lot more about--was not poppycock but the result of the synthesis and integration of many facts by the likes of Lister, Pasteur, Koch, Semmelweis, Leeuwenhoek, and others. 

This small vignette from a movie largely unrelated to the topic gives a brief glimpse into what those heroic individuals had to overcome in order to usher in an era of vaccines, antibiotics, the entire medical speciality of infectious diseases, and ever increasing life spans.

"Venereal" Musings on The Theory of Everything

"Is it venereal?" 

That was the question posed to Stephen Hawking in the movie The Theory of Everything  by his roommate after Hawking states he has been diagnosed with a disease as portrayed in the movie  As is common knowledge, Professor Hawking has waged an odds-defying battle with the debilitating Lou Gehrig's Disease (ALS)--something definitely not venereal--while at the same time building an astonishingly productive career devoted to contemplating the widest of possible abstractions.

But, in a weird coincidence (or maybe I'm just stretching this) Hawking's work has something in common with venereal matters. The concept venereal derives from the Roman term for the goddess of love and beauty, Venus, whose name was given to the brightest object in the sky (excluding the sun and the moon): the 2nd planet from the sun. Diseases that arose while pursuing "love" were, therefore, named for the patron goddess of love.

My favorite fact about Professor Hawking that isn't widely known is that his father Dr. Frank Hawking was an expert in parasitic infectious diseases such as malaria, trypanosomiasis, and filariasis and headed the parasitology branch of the UK's National Institute for Medical Research. I think it must've been incredible to hear dinner conversations in which one person is talking about microscopic organisms and the other massive black holes and stars.

I found the movie was in many ways inspirational as it explicitly endorsed the idea that there is no limit to human endeavor and did not shy away from Professor Hawking's atheism.

One quote in particular I found very illuminating was: "A physicist can't allow his calculations to be muddled by belief in a supernatural creator." I think it is a broadly applicable piece of advice that applies to all endeavors and instructs us that reality, the knowledge of which is pursued through the faculty of reason, is the ultimate arbiter of the veracity of our work. Any consideration that undercuts that standard will muddle one's thinking because it involves placing something above one's reasoning mind.

With a poetic license of sorts, I take venereal to be reaching for the brightest stars in the skies--a goal we all should strive for.

A Fecal Transplant Chaser to Go With Your Antibiotics?

Infectious disease physicians continously warn of the danger of antibiotic overuse. This is often put in terms of increasing resistance, side effects, C.diff and costs. However, these often seem impersonal to the patient who is sick--usually from a viral infection--and is demanding an antibiotic (or even worse is a parent of a sick child). To them, even the threat of a side effect is outweighed by the potential benefit they believe they will gain from an antibiotic.  

Powerful evidence has begin to amount, however, that the danger of antibiotic misuse is much greater than the (still true) standard answers. This answer revolves around alterations in the microbiome that are induced by exposure to antibiotics.

To back up, shortly after birth humans are literally covered with bacteria in almost every crevice of their body (skin, digestive tract, mucosal surfaces)--the microbiome or microbiota. These organisms perform vital functions for us that include metabolizing certain substances, preventing "bad" bacteria from gaining hold, and interacting with myriad cells from multiple organ systems (including the nervous system). When this retinue of bacteria is disrupted by antibiotics, certain microbes go "missing" and the result is not good. 

All this, as an infectious disease physician, I knew but no where had I seen it presented in a manner that lists the litany of microbiome disruptive diseases and summarizes the leading research in an easy comprehensible manner to provide the full context of the issue. That all changed with the publication of Dr. Martin Blaser's Missing Microbes: How the Overuse of Antibiotics is Fueling Our Modern Plagues which I just finished.

In this book Dr. Blaser, whose work I think will make him a household name in the future, catalogs and expertly explains the importance of the microbiome and theorizes, with ample evidence, that such modern plagues as autism, asthma, reflux, obesity and esophageal cancer may have their origin in the alteration of the microbiome, induced largely by antibiotics (as well as birth via C-section). The point he makes is that anything that prevents an infant from acquiring the microbiome that humans evolved with--whether it be antibiotics or a birth canal-bypassing c-section--will have ramifications. 

I once heard a lecture by Dr. Arturo Casadevall in which he described how infectious diseases physicians of the future will spend their time. His answer: microbiome specialists. I am convinced of his and Dr. Blaser's predictions and can't wait to see how unexplained illnesses melt away when viewed in the context of the microbiome and what novel treatments are devised (probiotics, prebiotics, bacteriophages, etc,)

Maybe in the future the possible need for routine fecal transplants is something we can use to scare people out of unnecessary antibiotics?

Understanding The Power of Plagues: Context and History

During the time of the Ebola media whirlwind, I often reminded people that infectious diseases have been a force in history since the dawn of civilization. While I firmly believe that the basic motive force of history is ideas, infectious diseases have played supporting roles. 

The Plague of Athens during the Peloponnesian War, Justinian's Plague, and the death of Alexander the Great are some of the more ancient examples. Modern examples include the Black Death, the collapse of the Aztec Empire, Napoleon's retreat from Russia, the 1918 flu pandemic, and HIV.

With that context constantly in mind conditioning every bit of knowledge I have of infectious diseases, it was not hard for me to integrate the daily happenings of Ebola--which brought 3 nations to the brink of collapse--with the storied history of infectious diseases of past eras.

The Power of Plagues by Professor Irwin Sherman  does a very good job of cataloging such invaluable facts. When contemplating any current or future infectious disease outbreak, having the ability to activate this vast amount of information gives one a powerful tool with which to make predictions and understand the situation. 

I just finished this 2006 book and found it very relevant 8 years after publication and particularly so with respect to Ebola, even though it is not a formal part of the book. Specially when Sherman discusses how a society responds to a new disease it was almost as if I was reading a contemporary after-action report on the current Ebola outbreak, attesting to the validity of the principles identified. 

Most of the contents of the books were familiar to me but Sherman's explanations of popular nursery rhymes, words, and activities whose origin can be traced to disease were somewhat new. Also, the presentation of malaria, the discovery of viruses, and other topics proceed in a very inductive manner which allows one to follow the key discoveries in a manner that retraces how the intellectual progression developed.

For those who want an easily digestible overview of the topic of infectious disease, this book would serve the purpose well (and would even benefit more expert readers).

Jonas Salk: An Original Scorpion Team Member

Last night on the CBS show Scorpion one of Pittsburgh's most esteemed former residents was mentioned: Dr. Jonas Salk.  For those who don't know, Scorpion is a show about a team of geniuses that assists the Department of Homeland Security with special problem--a premise I find fascinating.

The context of the Jonas Salk mention was regarding the strategies needed to tackle difficult problems. Specifically, when Salk was solving the problem of the polio vaccine he battened down and thought through the problem and didn't just wish that things would go his way. This is the admonition to  never putting anything above the facts of reality, or as Ayn Rand succinctly put it, never put an "I wish" above an "it is"--something that physicians and scientists, especially, must never forget. 

Being from Pittsburgh, Jonas Salk has a special resonance with me. I have heard countless stories from people who knew or met him and I'm a bit jealous of their opportunity. Walking around Pittsburgh, being an odd person, I sometimes think about what it would be like to see him walking down the road, getting a slice of pizza, or other things that I do in Pittsburgh every day. In the book Splendid Solution: Jonas Salk and the Conquest of Polio--which I highly recommend--it details his almost ritual lunch at a now long gone Chinese restaurant where The Pittsburgh Press (also long gone) science reporter John Troan would try to get an indication of what was transpiring with the polio vaccine work that ultimately changed the face of this dread disease. 

One scene in particular really grips me. After the resounding success of the clinical trial of the vaccine was announced in Michigan, Dr. Salk returned to Pittsburgh and was greeted by throngs of people expressing their thanks for he and his team's achievement. His motorcade had a police escort. Imagining Dr. Salk receiving the fanfare almost exclusively reserved for the Pittsburgh Penguins, Pittsburgh Steelers, and the Pittsburgh Pirates is kind of exhilarating and I can almost experience the sense of justice and Pittsburgh pride that must have electrified the air on that day.

I am glad that Scorpion, a show whose theme I believe revolves around the crucial survival value of intelligence saw fit to pay homage to one of the real life examples that concretizes the veracity of its theme.